Hello and welcome to another glorious week of Commander finance. I’m your host, Jim, and today we’re going to take a look at some terribly early leaks of the new Commander set. They’ve been around for a long enough time and nobody has refuted their authenticity. That suggests to me that they’re unfortunately very real. What we can do from this information is try to predict how players will react to the new cards and save a few bucks if you’re interested in making a new deck!
Most Commander decks are a mix of new Commanders and old Commanders (with the exception of the last set since there were previously no four-color legendary creatures). Usually, it’s two new legends and one reprint. In Commander 2015 we had Daxos the Returned and Karlov of the Ghost Council as new Commanders while Teysa, Envoy of Ghosts was a returning Commander. This Commander set is already throwing a wrench in that idea a little because it has three new Commanders (Ramos, Dragon Engine, The Ur-Dragon, and O-Kagachi, Vengeful Kami) and one returning Commander (Scion of the Ur-Dragon). Given the fact that Scion of the Ur-Dragon is the only five color legendary dragon, it isn’t surprising that it is included.
Ultimately what is going to be important to know is what is in the deck and what is not. The entire decklists have not been spoiled yet but the cards that have been spoiled as reprints are:
- Broodmate Dragon
- Steel Hellkite
- Haven of the Spirit Dragon
- Sandsteppe Citadel
- Spellbound Dragon
- Tyrant's Familiar
- Crucible of the Spirit Dragon
- Ojutai, Soul of Winter
- Silumgar, the Drifting Death
- Kolaghan, the Storm's Fury
- Dromoka, the Eternal
- Atarka, World Render
- Bladewing the Risen
- Crosis, the Purger
- Intet, the Dreamer
- Niv-Mizzet, Dracogenius
This isn’t the whole decklist and doesn’t include a lot of the staples of Scion of the Ur-Dragon decks. Those are the cards we need to consider and pay attention to see if they get spoiled. My favorite resource to use to figure out what people are playing in their EDH decks is EDHREC.com. This page shows us what aggregate five color dragon decks look like and what are the most important and expensive cards in the deck.
Taking a look at the cards that aren’t included and aren’t specifically a Scion of the Ur-Dragon synergy card (aka Teneb), I’m left with a lot of cards that could get a lot cheaper if they’re included or pretty expensive if they’re not.
As you can see above, Hellkite Tyrant saw a huge spike right around Fate Reforged and continued climbing during Dragons of Tarkir. Turns out if you print 10 new legendary dragons people get excited about big powerful dragons. Most recently, it had begun to pick up steam again until it was reprinted in Commander 2016 around the time of Kaladesh. If Utvara Hellkite is included, then I expect it to see a similar trend down. It will probably drop from about $7 to $3 and then slowly creep back up. If it’s not included, it will be $10 or more very quickly. If you don’t really keep up with spoilers and want to worry about it but want to play some sweet five color dragons, I’d recommend buying this guy now. It’s the kind of card that will recover eventually from a Commander printing and is pretty safe to buy now.
Another very popular and powerful card in dragon Commander decks that I’m watching is Balefire Dragon. It’s only been printed once at mythic in Innistrad but it’s got a powerful affect that lets you basically kill all of your opponent’s stuff. It’s probably up for a reprint at this point in time but if it is missed I would be surprised if it didn’t jump a few more dollars. It’s $12 now but could easily be $20 if enough players realize it’s a powerful dragon they don’t own.
The last card from EDHREC I want to talk about is Sarkhan Unbroken. They don’t often include Planeswalkers in Commander decks and also have very few reprint mythics. This card fixes your mana and fits the dragon theme while having a game over ultimate if you have a Karrthus in your deck. It’s $6.50 while seeing basically no competitive play in some really awkward colors for dragons. I think this is one of the first cards players will latch on to and add to their decks. The potential for a huge temporary price jump is pretty real.
While there are a lot of cards that are pretty obvious because they’re dragons or have to do with dragons, I am very concerned about what the mana situation is going to look like in this deck. They’ve done 4 color Commander decks with some pretty bad mana. In this five color deck we already see the Khans of Tarkir tri-lands and some dragon specific dual lands but what mana rocks are they going to include? Coalition Relic, Prismatic Geoscope, Chromatic Lantern, Gilded Lotus, and Quicksilver Amulet are all cards this type of deck would want but unlikely that you get all of them. We saw last time when Chromatic Lantern was only included in one deck that it dipped a little bit before going above what it was before it got reprinted. At this point it’s too early to tell what they’re going to end up adding into the deck but if you make a short list of cards to watch it might be wise to buy them now rather than waiting. It’s not always the case that the cards get cheaper after being reprinted.
While I outlined some cards to keep an eye on, I’m still of the opinion that wait and see is the best course of action. Some people bought out Zirilan of the Claw because “it’s good in EDH” but that spike is entirely brought on by people trying to make money on the card and not those trying to play it. That kind of culture is dangerous to interact with because it can cause a lot of people to panic buy assuming this is the new price. I would be very surprised if Zirilan isn’t back under $5 in a few months as buylists on that card have barely budged. Take a look at the cards with real demand with higher percentage buylists like the cards I’ve listed above if you want to get ahead of the dragon hype!