CoolStuffInc.com

Turn your cards into cash! Maximize your value with our 25% store credit bonus!
   Sign In
Create Account

The Ultimate Guide to the Commander Format in Magic: The Gathering

Reddit

So, you've heard about this card game called Commander that everyone is playing now. You want to get involved? Here is the ultimate guide to Magic Commander rules.

This is for getting started if you aren't familiar with Commander as a format. We'll walk through all the basics -- and a little more too -- in this article. You'll be an expert in no time!

The Ultimate Guide to the Commander Format in Magic: The Gathering

An Brief Introduction to Magic: The Gathering Formats

Magic: the Gathering is an complex game with many different formats & ways to play. A format is a set of rules that apply to how you deck build, win, how many players you have, and the pool of cards you have access to.

Some of these formats are Standard, Pauper, and Commander. They all have their own unique structures and rules.

The format we're focusing on today is Commander. It was a fan-started format that got official support by Wizards of the Coast (WOTC) in June of 2011.

What is the Commander Format?

Commander, informally known as EDH (which was its original name), is a singleton format.

It's a casual format -- so less competitive than something like Standard -- though sub-formats of Commander like cEDH exist. We'll get more into cEDH later, but it is a competitive approach to the casual format Commander with extreme focus on deck optimization and strategy.

Commander Deckbuilding & Basic Rules

A Commander deck consists of a Commander(s) and 99 (or 98 if there are two Commanders or a Background) cards. It forms a 100-card singleton deck. That means that aside from basic lands, you can only have one copy of any particular card in your deck. We will get into what a "Commander" is later.

Your starting life total is 40 and it's a free-for all-style multi-player format, allowing any number for opponents. The ideal number is four players. You usually win when all your opponents' life totals hit zero (There are other ways to win, but we'll leave the most often and accessible one here).

Tip #1: Don't get overwhelmed. Play your first games of Commander with someone who has played before so you can double check the rules with someone experienced. That doesn't mean all newbies can't play together, but it will be more difficult.

What is your Commander?

The Commander format has a particularly unique feature called the "The Command Zone." This is a special zone where your Commander stays outside of your deck. A Commander is a Legendary Creature, Vehicle, or Spacecraft--and sometimes Planeswalker (those are special cases). Almost any Legendary from the beginning of Magic's history until now is a legal Commander. Unless they're banned.

Commander Color Identity

The interesting things don't end there. The color identity of your deck is based on the mana pips used to cast your Commander or mana pips included in its body text. Every card in your Commander deck must only use mana symbols that also appear on your Commander.

For example; in a Hashaton, Scarab's Fist deck; you can play Blue u, Black b, and White w identity cards. You can play Tortured Existence and Frantic Search in this deck. There are a lot of specifics about Color Identity that we won't cover here, but you read about them.

Commanders live in the Command Zone. You may cast it from here for its mana cost plus 2 for each time you've cast it from this zone previously. So, the first time is free and two more each time. Notably it cares about if it's cast from the Command Zone, so sending it to the graveyard or hand means it is cast normally and without the tax.

Commander Damage

Lastly, Commander Damage is a unique mechanic for Commander. If a player takes 21 pts of combat damage to a player, they lose the game as if their life total hit zero. This can happen all at once or over the course of several turns. Each Commander deals its own amount of damage for this threshold, and this total is tracked throughout the game.

Tip #2: When selecting a Commander, choose from a more popular one or one from a preconstructed deck (we'll get into preconstructed decks later). It can be difficult building a deck with little insight. The more popular the deck, the more information there is about how to build one.

Commander-Legal Sets

Commander is sort of a casual Eternal Format like Vintage and Legacy. Every card that has been printed in Magic's history is playable so long as it isn't banned. Virtually all published Magic sets are legal in Commander. Even sets that aren't legal for Standard are legal in Commander. This makes deck building options diverse.

Commander Banned List

The Banned and Restricted lists come out every so often for all games. Commander usually has its own announcements. The most recent update for the Banned and Restricted list for Commander came out on February 9th, 2026.

This list is used to decide which cards are too powerful, too unfun, or too streamlined to be allowed in the Commander format. Sometimes cards get removed from the banned list and are put on the Game Changer list. Before we get into the Game Changer list, we must explain the Bracket System.

Tip #3: Follow Magic's official website on your socials. There are rulings and changes to the format coming through a few times a year and you want to keep yourself informed. They post about changes on their socials.

The Bracket System

Because Commander is a casual format with access to nearly 30,000 cards since the start of the format and is a multiplayer format, it's hard for it to be exactly competitive. People opt to focus on the fun aspect of the game more, but balancing the power and experience of the game is difficult to quantify.

A group called the Commander Format Panel decided to tackle this problem. They invented something called the Beta Bracket system. Their site states, "In each bracket description, you'll also find guidance around four kinds of effects that can really impact games: two-card infinite combos, extra turns, mass Land denial, and tutors (for things other than Lands), noting where and how you should expect to see them."

They included Game Changers which is a list of cards that indicate in some way the expectation of power in the deck. In a later update that talked more about intention and expectation and turns to win , to modify the system further.

Tip #4: Brackets are hard to quantify. Don't overthink them. Try to follow them as best you can by being open and flexible about how your decks are interpreted. Just be honest and it'll work out.

Commander Game Changers

Game Changers are cards that "change the game." They're cards that warp Commander games around them. It gives players more advantage and resources or are cards players dislike so much due to how efficient or oppressive they can be. There are updates to this list as things are unbanned and moved to this list or things are added to Game Changers from just socially recognized strong cards.

Tip #5: Only worry about your Game Changers after you've built your deck. When it's done, go through the list and see where you deck falls. It helps keep the process honest.

Where to Play Commander

Once you've figured out the basics of the game, you're going to be looking for somewhere to play. There are a lot of options since Commander has become more popular. You don't necessarily have to go in person to a local game store (LGS).

Paper and In-Person

A lot of players are going to tell you that you need to play Commander in paper at an LGS. This is a great place to learn the basics with someone who might teach you, but there are a lot of concerns about finding a friendly enough space to help you. Not all LGSs are friendly and open to new players or even nearby.

Some good ways to get started are online.

MTG Arena

MTG Arena is a good way to get started in Magic in general because it is an automated system that walks you through what you can and cannot do in a game. It also walks you through the mana system and paying costs and to some extent when you can interact.

While MTG Arena doesn't have Commander, it has a 1v1 format like Commander called Brawl. It might be a good starting point to learn the mechanics of Commander. Playing some here could prepare you for Spelltable.

Convoke/Spelltable

There are a handful of programs you can use to play in paper but online with a webcam. Spelltable is the WOTC official program, but things like Convoke are alternatives that rock too. It's a very fun way to play Commander with people all over.

These programs have card detectors and ways to keep track of life totals. They have microphones built in to talk about interaction too. It's all very great.

Tip #6: Whichever platform you choose, keep an eye on Brackets. Newer players should opt to play around Bracket 2-3. It makes sure you are playing with people who are comfortable with new or lower power play styles.

Commander Precons (Preconstructed Decks)

When talking about getting started, you might feel motivated to make a deck from scratch. This is very difficult just starting out, but WOTC has a product just for you! It's called a preconstructed deck, or a precon.

These are decks with Commanders and game plans built in to help new players get started without having to buy all the necessary pieces individually. They're low cost but often lower powered. They're great jumping off points for making stronger decks through, with minor to major upgrades.

Tip #7: When you first start playing to ask for Precon games. Players usually understand what that means and will play accordingly. It'll be an easier game to follow and play against.

Popular Commander Resources

There are a ton of resources you should be using once you get in Commander. The best deckbuilding resource is probably EDHREC.com. This site breaks down the top Commanders and the top cards being played by players all over the world. It's a great starting point for how to improve a precon or get inspiration for a new deck.

Spelltable and Convoke are great places to get games in with people around the world, test decks, and dive straight into some games with strangers or friends. CoolStuffInc is a great place to buy singles and sealed product for your decks -- like sleeves and deckboxes -- with quick shipping and reasonable prices.

The MTG subreddit and The Comprehensive Rules when used in tandem are a great way to double check how certain interactions are resolved in the game. Magic is a complex game with unique interactions. It gets confusing how something works and using these two resources together you can parse out how it works.

Tip #8: Buy singles, or individual card listings, when deckbuilding. Buying booster packs means you spend more money and likely won't get what you're looking for. CoolStuffInc has tons of cards, accessories, and peripherals for playing Magic.

cEDH vs. Casual EDH

As you move along your journey, you'll see something called Bracket 5, or cEDH. This stands for Competitive Elder Dragon Highlander, or competitive Commander. It's a version of Commander that is super streamlined and efficient, playing the best cards in the format. It has a unique meta that can win on any turn, even its first turn.

It's not the sort of thing new players need to partake in, but it is a very fun and exciting aspect of what Commander can do. It's as serious and powerful as Commander can get.

Everything that doesn't have the specific internal meta and efficiency of this sub-format is casual Commander. It doesn't mean it's not powerful and serious, but considerably more casual in those regards.

Tip #9: cEDH is really fun, but proxying expensive cards like Lion's Eye Diamond might be the best way to see if you want to invest in playing cEDH. Make sure to check with your playgroup before proxying expensive cards.

Commander Variant

There are a lot of different ways to play Commander. There are various variant ways to play. Whether it's changing the rules about who is can be your Commander, how many players you need, your life total, or a whole other deck all the following formats are Commander variants in one way or another that you could play.

Tip #10: Stick to regular Commander for a while to master it before venturing off into any of these other variants.

Oathbreaker

Oathbreaker is 60-card variant of Commander. It uses planeswalkers and a signature spell in the command zone. The signature spell can only be cast when you control your planewalker though. It's neat. All other aspects stay the same

Pendragon

Pendragon is a variant that has a common Creature and a Legendary Equipment in the command zone instead of a Legendary Creature or Vehicle. You start with 30 life as well. All other aspects stay the same.

Kingdoms

Kingdoms have a unique set of rules. "Kingdoms is a Mafia-like Commander variant that uses secret roles to determine players' allies, enemies, and win conditions," according to Commander's Herald.

There are roles for each of six players. The player with the plains is the emperor. The player with a forest is the knight and is on the emperor's side. Each player with mountains are bandits and win if the emperor is defeated.

The player with a swamp is the assassin and wins when everyone else is eliminated. The Usurper is the player with the island and wins when they deal the killing blow to the emperor. The usurper goes to 50 and the roles between them switch, setting the previous emperor to one. It's neat.

Tiny Leaders

Tiny leaders is a 50-card variant consisting only of cards with mana value three or less. There is a 10 card sideboard, and players starting life total is 20. Starting hand is based on eight minus the amount of cards in the command zone.

It is practically its own format, sharing only the command zone, singleton format, and color identity build around.

Pauper Commander

Pauper Commander has two major differences from Commander. One, Uncommon creature can your Commander. Two, all the cards in your deck must be printed in common rarity at some point. All other rules are the same.

Brawl

"Brawl is a Standard-legal Commander variant where any legendary creature or planeswalker can be used as your Commander," according to Commander's Herald. It's a 60-card format that starts at 30 life for multiplayer and 25 for 1v1. Any planeswalker can be a Commander. It has its own banned and restricted list.

Secret Partners

Secret Partners is a variant where players are secretly assigned a partner. A player wins when all other players aside from them and their secret partner are eliminated. Everyone has different partners. If your partner dies then you can no longer win. Otherwise it's a normal game of Commander.

Archenemy

Archenemy is a variant where a single player faces off against three others. The Archenemy has a something called a scheme deck -- a deck of its own -- that reveals and activates each turn. These cards are very powerful. Aside from that it has normal rules for Commander.

Planechase

Planechase is another variant with its own deck. The planechase deck is a 10-card deck that has various planes with various effects. Players can roll planar dies to planeswalk the pod to a new plane with new triggered or static effects. The first roll is free on each of your turns and one generic more for each additional roll.

Why is Commander often referred to as EDH?

Before Commander was a legal format through Wizards of the Coast, it was a fan made format known as EDH. It stood for Elder Dragon Highlander, harkening back to the Highlander movie's famous line, "There can only be one!" It was played originally with Elder Dragons like Chromium and Arcades Sabboth as Commanders.

The official term is Commander, but EDH is a hard thing to let go. Lots of players learn it that way and still call it that. Both mean the same game. though.

Why is Commander so popular?

Commander is a popular format because of how communal it is. People can gather, get snacks, talk, and play together. It's creative, allowing players to build strategically and flavor-wise. It's complex and stimulates the problem-solvers in us. It's financially more accessible than competitive formats--not having to buy new stuff for each set to keep up with the meta.

There are a lot of reasons Commander is popular but mainly it's because of Universes Beyond bringing in players from all walks of life with IPs they like. The more common place the game is, the more socially infectious it can become. More and more players get into the game every day.

Conclusion

There you have it! The ultimate guide to Commander Magic. I hope these rules and tips along the way helped. This list isn't exhaustive at any rate. You will be using all the resources and even more, but I hope this was helpful. Let me know how your journey is going! I'm @strixhavendropout on everything.

Send us your cards, we'll do the rest. Ship It. No Fees. Fast Payment. Full Service Selling!

Sell your cards 25% credit bonus